so i went and saw “sicko” June 30, 2007
Last night , Jon and I joined some friends and a bunch of fellow Knoxville bloggers to go see Michaell Moore’s new movie, “Sicko.”
It is my hope that this movie, which is as Cathy says MORE A FORM OF POLITICAL PROTEST than a documentary, will one day be seen as the watershed moment that finally galvanized Americans to action on this critical issue..
Moore posits that our medical care system is completely broken. He focuses on three major points in exploring his thesis:
-Millions of Americans have zero health insurance, meaning they are living without any access to even the simplest health care.
-Even for Americans who have “good” health care, it’s a big, confusing ripoff. You pay your big premiums each month (and your employer is also paying out the nose), and while you may be “covered” if you get sick — and be able to get the treatment you need — you will then be bombarded by huge bills for uncovered services, copays and deductibles. Many, many insured Americans end up losing everything when the bills start rolling in after major medical care is needed.
-The fact that medical insurance companies are for-profit means that they will always seek to avoid paying for as many services as possible, meaning that many insured Americans needing medical care are denied treatments. Some of them die. Many of them suffer. And health insurance execs are among the most highly compensated Americans, making salaries in the 6 and 7 figures off the backs of a syetem where millions are struggling to pay their premiums and get the care they need.
One of my favorite parts of the movie was Moore’s conversation with the wildly entertaining elderly British Labour leader TONY BENN, who explained how the British ended up with nationalized health service (NHS). Benn, and the other British citizens (and some Americans living in London) Moore spoke with, obviously hold the NHS up as a point of patriotic pride. Started in 1948, as the British were reeling in the aftermath of what they had lived through in WWII, the NHS marked a sense of national hope and identity - a way for the Brits to say “we take care of our own — all of our own.”
That idea of “taking care of our own” was echoed by the every day Canadians with whom Moore spoke. They simply believe that it’s the upstanding thing to do to make sure that all of their neighbors have access to health care, and they are willing to pay part of their own incomes to provide it. It’s a low drama approach. It’s not about politics or fear of the socialist bogeyman or Hillary Clinton…they see it as simply The Right Thing To Do.
One of the most disturbing parts of the movie, and a sidenote of American history of which I hadn’t been aware, is how Edgar Kaiser (the guy behind the first and largest American HMO) convinced the Nixon administration to get behind HMOs by explaining that he had created profit incentives in his health insurance business to pay as little as possible in health care claims.
I support universal health care for all Americans. I supported it before I saw this movie and I support it more strongly now. There are various ways we could create such a system, but as the only western industrialized nation without universal health care, it’s absurd to suggest that it cannot be done.
I will likely write more about the movie and my thoughts on this issue later, but for now I am going to walk down the street to my neighborhood market and get a Coke. My favorite cashier there, Britney, is due back from her two week maternity leave today, and I think I’ll drop a few more dollars in the several jars and cans set up on the counter begging for help for various children in our community who are in need of operations and chemo that their parents cannot afford.












